Pictured above: Jonathan Turner
Legislation introduced in the Health and Social Care Bill will
mean NHS Trusts could save up to 40 per cent of their annual
property costs by acquiring properties and refinancing PFI and
lease commitments, according to global real estate services firm
DTZ.
The Health and Social Care Bill 2011, which completed the
Committee Stage of its passage through Parliament on 31 March,
makes sweeping changes to the Prudential Borrowing Code for Trusts.
It removes statutory borrowing limits imposed under the National
Health Service Act 2006, enabling NHS Foundation Trusts to borrow
freely.
The new range of freedoms will allow Foundation Trusts to
self-determine affordable borrowing limits for investment in
capital projects. Health sector lending is available at low-cost
rates of 3.5 per cent, based on gilt yields. The resulting
imbalance between a Trust's cost of borrowing and the cost of
current property and PFI obligations means it could be far more
cost-effective for NHS Trusts to acquire the properties and buy
themselves out of PFI and lease contracts.
Jonathan Turner, Head of DTZ's Public Sector Practice Group in
the Midlands, comments: "We have advised local authorities who have
had access to similar cost-efficient prudential borrowing since
2004 and have made savings of typically 30-40 per cent.
"NHS Trusts are now in a position to apply the same model, which
could deliver annual savings of £3-4 million for a Trust with
yearly PFI or lease costs of £10 million."
Richard Shield, Head of the Healthcare Practice Group at DTZ,
comments: "The Health Bill's overhaul of the Prudential Borrowing
Code means that Trusts can exploit their access to cheap debt to
buy such assets from the providers, significantly reducing annual
repayments year on year.
"It is clear that public funding for significant capital
projects is unlikely to be forthcoming, so private finance is
likely to remain a necessity where there is a clearly identified
need for investment, in a new hospital for example. However, DTZ
estimates that, if all NHS Trusts were in a position to buy out PFI
contracts, this could deliver savings in excess of £300
million in the first year, rising in every subsequent year of the
contracts.
"Whilst over the lifetime of the contracts this could equate to
savings in the region of £15 to £20 billion, it is
likely that, in the first instance, only smaller PFI contracts will
offer real opportunity for immediate savings.
"The case is most persuasive where the Trust is tied in to a
lease or PFI commitment in excess of ten years. However, we believe
that all Trusts now have the opportunity to review their
commitments and could realise some serious savings on public
expenditure."