Pictured above: (l-r) Challinors' Fraud & Asset
Recovery lawyers Arun Chauhan and Mark Kenkre
The Financial Services Authority (FSA) has ramped up the number
of investigations into insider trading in the last three months,
stepping up its efforts to crack down on market manipulation.
According to fraud lawyers at Midlands firm Challinors, the
forthcoming election will determine any future government policy,
but in the short-term, there is little doubt that fraud and
financial crime will continue to be high on the political agenda.
Challinors' joint head of the Fraud & Asset Recovery
department Arun Chauhan comments: "Under the leadership of Margaret
Cole, the FSA is stepping-up its efforts to crack-down on market
manipulation, demonstrated by the marked increase already this year
in the number of investigations into insider trading. The FSA has
been cracking-down on insider trading for the past two years but
the approach it is now taking is markedly different.
"Insider trading involves trading stock or other securities by
individuals who have potential access to non-public information
about the company, and this is a criminal offence in the United
Kingdom under the Criminal Justice Act 1993.
"The FSA has recently produced data that suggests around 30
percent of all trading that takes place in the two days before a
takeover is announced could be influenced by inside information.
Insider trading is said to be rife but prosecutions can take up to
two years from arrest to charge as building a case is extremely
complicated and requires the regulator to sift through a lot of
complex information," he says.
"In the last month alone, there have been dawn raids and arrests
in the City of London. Previous efforts have looked at fringe
players such as interns at investment banks, retired stockbrokers
and employees at second-tier firms, but in these latest
investigations, leading players have been arrested, which has
struck at the heart of the city."
According to Challinors' Mark Kenkre, who heads up the firm's
specialist Fraud team alongside Arun, two recent examples show just
how seriously insider trading is now being taken, and how keen the
desire of the FSA is to seek its first extradition for insider
trading: "A suspect in the French territory in the Comoros Islands
was detained and a European Arrest warrant was issued by the FSA.
The FSA has also launched 'Project Saturn', an insider dealing
investigation which has seen a former employee of a top City
spread-betting firm charged."
So what of the future and in the run-up to the general election?
Arun says: "The FSA must look at the delicate balance of when
normal market behaviour becomes criminality which is why a case is
so difficult to prove. Whilst the FSA is now targeting leading City
individuals, it should also serve as a warning to any professional
with sensitive market information who should not use such
information for their own benefit."
Mark adds: "The Authority has brought proceedings against
solicitors in the past for insider trading in relation to corporate
deals, which should serve as a warning to those in the legal
profession. There has always been a duty of confidentiality, but if
solicitors are tempted to use information themselves or pass it to
third parties, they risk not just being struck from the register
but could also face a custodial sentence.
"The economic downturn has seen a marked increase in fraud and
financial crime. Even in the lifespan of the downturn there have
been trends emerging and it would appear the FSA is now keen to put
a marker down to demonstrate that market manipulation will not be
tolerated and that the financial sector will have to become
accustomed to regulatory bodies well and truly turning the
spotlight on them."
Challinors has offices in Birmingham, West Bromwich,
Wolverhampton, Halesowen and Nottingham. The firm has 24 partners
and over 100 fee earners, and is ranked as one of the top legal
firms in the West Midlands, being Number 1 in the Chambers UK
Directory in a number of categories, including Clinical
Negligence.