Pictured above: Karen Macpherson
We could be entering a new age of industrial strife, a leading
employment lawyer has claimed.
And Karen Macpherson, employment partner at the Birmingham
office of DLA Piper, warned that unions were getting smarter in
their international links.
Speaking as the British Airways cabin crew strikes dominate the
headlines, she cautioned: "It really opens the gates for potential
long term chaos at our airports.
"And, with a number of other unions flexing their muscles for
possible action, the fear is that we may be headed for a troubled
industrial relations period.
"This often happens after recessions have forced job losses and
pay cuts. Once better times materialise, the dam of frustration
that has built up suddenly bursts.
"Let's hope this does not happen again for the sake of
industrial relations and the future of the economy, but the signs
are ominous.
"And if a Conservative administration gets in at the coming
General Election, imposing tough pay restrictions on the public
sector, things might just get worse before they get better."
Highlighting the cross border links between unions, Ms
Macpherson continued: "Trade unions across the world were flashing
up on the radar in support of the striking British Airways cabin
crew to the dismay of the airline's management and passengers.
"Unions in over 120 countries representing various aviation roles
including cabin crew, pilots, ground staff, baggage handlers and
air traffic controllers claimed to be ready to support the BA
strikers. This is clear evidence of the increasing globalisation of
trade unions.
"In recent years unions have been seeking to extend their
international reach to apply pressure to more susceptible parts of
an international business, targeting specific domestic operations
and also 'exporting' industrial disputes.
"While in the UK and Australia 'sympathy strikes' are illegal
and can be squashed with an injunction from the relevant court or
industrial tribunal, other countries allow solidarity action. And
the TWU in Australia were citing health and safety concerns for
their workers in servicing BA planes that could be staffed with
inexperienced, untrained and unskilled strike breakers."
The Unite union has confirmed that it will not strike over
Easter, but warned there could be further action after April 14 if
a resolution has not been agreed.
Ms Macpherson noted: "The terms of the ballot taken by the union
allow them to opt for further action at any time as long as it
relates to the same dispute. So unless a resolution is reached, we
could see further disruption in the coming months and even into the
summer.
As to the conduct of the dispute, she said BA could lawfully
discipline and sack staff for bullying and harassment, but if the
reason for the action was their role as trade union officials
during a strike, that could lead to an "automatic unfair dismissal
case".
The distinction between official and unofficial industrial
action is key. An employee who is involved in industrial action
will usually be in breach of their employment contract and the
employer may be able to deduct pay or dismiss them. However, if the
industrial action is 'official', the participating employees have
some protection against dismissal.
There is no specific legal restriction on an employer using
temporary agency workers to cover for striking workers. There are,
however, legal restrictions on the agency which supplies the
workers. Nevertheless there is nothing to stop an organisation
hiring fixed term employees directly to cover for striking
workers.