Flint Bishop

Equality Bill still offers strong protection according to Birmingham based lawyer at DLA Piper

Even though the Government has backed down from a confrontation with religious leaders over proposed changes to the Equality Bill, the law still offers considerable protection, according to a Birmingham lawyer.

The row centred on proposed amendments to the Equality Bill, which the Pope said would force the Catholic Church to employ homosexuals or trans-sexuals. This, he claimed, would be a violation of natural law.

The controversial clause, which was struck out of the legislation during committee stage in the House of Lords last week, would have included a new definition of a priest but church leaders claimed it was far too narrow.However, Imogen Noons, an associate in the employment department at the Birmingham office of DLA Piper, said she had never believed the equality row over who churches can employ was likely to get out of hand.

But, she pointed out, although there are still more than adequate safeguards in both existing legislation and the wording of the proposed Bill, there was nevertheless the potential for high profile "cause celebre" cases.

Her comments came as DLA Piper prepares to launch a series of employment and pension law seminars, with equality one of the areas up for discussion.

The furore was created by elements of the Equality Bill, which is currently going through Parliament.

Pope Benedict highlighted his concerns while confirming he would make the first papal visit to Britain since 1982, probably in September this year.

The church, which remains at odds with the Government on gay adoption, said that as well as being forced to employ homosexuals and trans-sexuals it might have to employ teachers who did not believe in God.

It remains the case that churches are exempt from discrimination legislation when appointing priests and other "religious" posts, but that they must comply with its terms for "non-religious" jobs, such as youth workers or accountants.

The Equality Bill had sought to clarify, rather than change the position as, though enshrined in law since 2003, it has been widely ignored.

This means the law will remain as it is.

Ms Noons said: "I can foresee some high profile cases being thrown up in the courts.

"But I don't believe the worst fears of the Pope and others are likely to materialise.

"There are clearly controversial issues concerning the church and homosexuality, but, when it comes to something like teaching, why would anyone want to apply for a job in a Catholic school who fundamentally disagreed with the Catholic faith? Furthermore the school would still be entitled to stipulate that they had to teach in accordance with the beliefs of the church

"I do not believe the Act, assuming it passes into law, will have as great an effect on employment law generally as everyone seems to think it will. A lot of the Act is an attempt to codify the existing legislation."

Royal Assent is expected by the spring.

The Equality seminar takes place at DLA Piper's Birmingham office on April 29 and the series starts on February 18 with a discussion about the rights of agency workers, the self-employed and contractors.

It is being headed by Jon Bowen and Robert Forsyth.

Mr Bowen highlighted the prospect for tribunal cases where companies got it wrong - unfair dismissal rulings can now cost business £65,300.

He said: "This is an area where the law is changing all the time and employers need to be very aware."

 

 

Bookmark and Share

Article published by Midlands Business News on 10 February, 2010

Submit your company news and photographs to Midlands Business News via email news@midlandsbusinessnews.co.uk or submit news and events online here.

midlandsbusinessnews.co.uk is an online Midlands business news network and we welcome submissions of your company or business related news articles and event notifications.

 

 

Articles submitted by DLA Piper:



  • Planning shake up could mean fewer houses built – DLA Piper - click to read
  • Confusion threatens new anti-bribery regime - click to read
  • Insurance fraudsters could trip up in new crackdown – DLA Piper - click to read
  • DLA Piper warns of squeeze on industrial action next year - click to read
  • DLA Piper plays central role in deals worth £350m - click to read
  • Don’t create a frosty atmosphere over snow shows - click to read
  • DLA Piper scoops top property title - click to read
  • Midlands based employment expert fears confusion around new equality laws - click to read
  • Rawstrons take the high road - click to read
  • Warning on housing policy vacuum - click to read
  • Competition warning on property deals from DLA Piper - click to read
  • Birmingham lawyers dig deep for community project - click to read
  • Birmingham based DLA Piper team scoops industry accolade - click to read
  • Insurance law reform overdue – DLA Piper, Birmingham - click to read
  • Councils must plan together – DLA Piper, Birmingham - click to read
  • Midlands based law firm advise on keeping ahead of health and safety inspections - click to read
  • Religion is a minefield in the workplace warns Birmingham based law firm DLA Piper - click to read
  • Birmingham based DLA Piper's smooth landing for Goodrich acquisition - click to read
  • No buts – you can still smoke at work - click to read
  • Birmingham based firm DLA Piper previews major changes in financial regulations - click to read
  • Birmingham based DLA Piper calls for clarity on future of SFO - click to read
  • DLA Piper advises on regeneration scheme for Wolverhampton - click to read
  • Public sector workers face World Cup red card says DLA Piper - click to read
  • DLA Piper closes £2.7bn deal for Birmingham Highways - click to read
  • Rising cost of insurance is hitting business say Birmingham based DLA Piper - click to read
  • Japanese investment remains crucial in West Midlands - click to read
  • Midlands based law firm DLA Piper advise on surviving and thriving under the Equality Act - click to read
  • Midland companies in the dark on bribery law - click to read
  • Midlands based law firm DLA Piper advise on coping with the flight ban - click to read
  • David Hayes to lead DLA Piper real estate team in Birmingham - click to read
  • Summer of discontent looms, warns Midlands based employment lawyer - click to read
  • DLA Piper appoints Russell Orme as new Managing Partner for Birmingham - click to read
  • Midlands based legal expert warns of tough new regime for corporate manslaughter - click to read
  • Midlands based law firm DLA Piper triumphs in recession-buster ski challenge - click to read
  • Midlands based law firm advise a good deal more M&A activity on the cards - click to read
  • Anti-bribery law must be taken seriously says DLA Piper - click to read
  • Five take a step up at DLA Piper in Birmingham - click to read
  • Equality Bill still offers strong protection according to Birmingham based lawyer at DLA Piper - click to read
  • New recruits for Birmingham law firm DLA Piper - click to read
  • Snowbound workers could face pay dock warns DLA Piper Birmingham - click to read
  • Hope for colleges hit by funding crisis - DLA Piper - click to read
  • Paternity leave fears may not materialise says DLA Piper - click to read
  • Green leases gain in popularity according to DLA Piper - click to read
  • Threatened workers could seek legal help - click to read
  • Royal Mail right on agency workers – DLA Piper - click to read
  • Some signs of hope, says banking legal expert - click to read
  • Sustainability pays, says Midlands legal expert - click to read
  • Employers warned as redundancy-related tribunals rocket, says DLA Piper, Birmingham - click to read
  • Birmingham law firm at the heart of Blackpool tramway upgrade - click to read
  • DLA Piper's M&A artists at work - click to read
  • Lawyers get net-wise to root out cheats says DLA Piper, Birmingham - click to read
  • Waiving a magic wand for struggling town centres - Peter Taylor of DLA Piper considers the options - click to read
  • Endangered species driving builders batty says Midlands law firm - click to read
  • Environmental warning for developers - click to read
  • UK bosses ill-prepared for Carbon Reduction Commitment says Midlands law firm DLA Piper - click to read
  • Don’t rely on letters of intent for payment says Birmingham office of DLA Piper - click to read
  • Search the site

    News Article
    Search



    Faces behind
    the business

    Nick Beham

    Nick Behan



    PressVine
    The Maynard Hotel
    Incentive & Motivation
    Klick Solutions Media
    Gourmet life

    Need a Service?

    Search our Midlands
    Business Directory