The Government's increasing but selective use of tax amnesties
is putting aside fairness in the pursuit of a quick boost to tax
revenues, according to a Birmingham accountant.
HM Revenue & Customs today (TUE JAN 12) launched a tax
amnesty for individuals registered with the General Medical Council
on terms that are very similar to the recent New Disclosure
Opportunity (NDO) for offshore assets.
Sarah Moss, tax manager at accountants and business advisers PKF
said: "We were told that the NDO was the last amnesty of its type.
Yet just a week after the NDO registration deadline passed, we have
a new amnesty that effectively says medics can still come clean
with, again, just a ten per cent penalty - even if any tax relating
to overseas assets will face a higher penalty. Presumably this
counts as a 'different type' of amnesty as far as HMRC is
concerned.
"Of course it is good to encourage individuals to disclose their
tax irregularities, but this approach is inconsistent. Individuals
could not use the NDO to disclose solely UK income; they had to
have overseas income or gains.
"The new amnesty, called the Tax Health Plan (THP), gives medics
the chance to disclose UK income from any source - not just
consulting fees and expenses. HMRC should encourage everyone with
irregularities to come forward and make amends by making similar
terms available to all taxpayers. That said, we know that HMRC has
been taking a close interest in the tax affairs of doctors and
consultants for some time and those with something to declare
should grab this good offer while they can."
Under the new amnesty, medical professionals can register by
March 31 to disclose unpaid tax over the past 20 years. They must
then make a full disclosure and pay any tax, interest and penalties
due by June 30 but, as with the NDO, penalties on UK source income
are limited to ten per cent - much lower than the penalty rate that
may be charged in other cases.
HMRC says: "The Tax Health Plan is the first initiative in a new
HMRC campaign focused on professionals," so further tax amnesties
for different sectors can be expected over the coming years.
Sarah Moss said: "After the original Offshore Disclosure
Facility (ODF) in 2007, there followed the NDO and the
Liechtenstein Disclosure Facility (LDF) last year. Now in 2010
there is the THP - one assumes that another amnesty will come along
in April for a new group.
"While I welcome any facility that helps people come forward,
HMRC should realise that the more amnesties there are, the more
confusion there is for the public and less attention people will
pay to them.
"Worse still, tax evaders who cannot benefit from the current
amnesty could be forgiven for thinking that they should just sit
tight because there will be another one along in a minute. That is
not the right thing to do in my opinion but such an attitude would
not be surprising in the circumstances."