More than 70 per cent of FTSE 350 companies implemented a pay
freeze for executive directors in 2009, according to a new report
by Deloitte.
The average increase, including those receiving zero, is likely
to be around 1.5 per cent to two per cent and where increases are
being given, the median increase is around three per cent to four
per cent, significantly lower than the six per cent to seven per
cent seen in the past few years.
Campbell Oswald, global employer services partner at Deloitte in
Birmingham, said: "Remuneration committees are responding both to
the economic situation and to pressure from investors, the media
and the general public. The majority have clearly concluded
that to award salary increases to executives in this difficult
climate would be inappropriate".
"This is the first time in a good many years that we have seen
executive salaries frozen and, even more unusually, we have seen
instances of some taking a salary cut."
Deloitte's analysis shows that although salaries may not be
increasing, annual bonuses have not yet been hit to the same
degree. While the potential bonus that may be earned has not
typically increased this year, in most cases it has not decreased
either.
Bonus plans also continue to pay out at a high level. Even when
looking only at the most recent reporting periods, the typical
payout is around two thirds of the potential amount.
"One might have expected bonus payouts to be significantly lower
this year," said Mr Oswald.
"But it is important to remember that for many companies,
performance during much of 2008 was still strong.
"We also should bear in mind that not all companies have been
impacted to the same degree. In the financial and property sectors,
which were hit earliest and hardest, the bonus payments are
significantly lower, at around 30 per cent of the maximum.
"We are aware of situations where directors have waived
the bonuses due to them. We also have seen remuneration committees
using discretion to reduce the level of award because the overall
performance of the company did not merit the payout generated by
the bonus formula.
"These actions are not something we have been used to seeing,
and do suggest that some companies are endeavouring to enforce the
link between pay and performance."
Deloitte's analysis shows that around one in four companies with
financial periods ending on or after December 2008 are planning to
change the performance measures on which the annual bonus is based
for the coming year.
Almost a quarter of FTSE 100 companies have either introduced an
element of deferral to the annual bonus plan, or increased the
proportion deferred and held in shares.
Mr Oswald said: "We have seen calls for more deferral of bonuses
in the financial services industry in response to the concern that
short term bonuses have led to excessive and inappropriate risk
taking. This message is clearly getting through, and across a much
wider spectrum than just financial services.
"We are also seeing a number of companies including clawback
provisions, although we anticipate that many of these provisions
would only be brought into force in exceptional circumstances.
"While many of the criticisms of excessive bonuses and
inappropriate risk taking are very specific to the banking
industry, we expect some of these issues to reverberate across all
industries.
"Ensuring that the remuneration of executives is strongly linked
to the business strategy and the long term health of the company,
and that incentive plans for executives do not encourage excessive
risk taking, is clearly in the interests of all companies."