The needs of protected species are in danger of sending builders
batty, according to law firm DLA Piper.
The likes of bats, great crested newts, otters and dormice now
have even greater protection.
According to Rachael Histead, an associate in the firm's
Birmingham office, two legal developments so far this year have
made the hurdles for developers even more difficult to
overcome.
She said: "There is no longer a clear distinction in the law
between low level and high level disturbance.
"An operator or developer who believes that his operation or
development could cause even low level disturbance must now
consider whether he needs to obtain a protected species licence
before carrying out the activities.
"It is no longer the case that the developer or operator can
assume that low level disturbance does not require a licence.
Licences will only be granted where strict legal tests are met.
These require the applicant to demonstrate that there are
'overriding public interest' reasons for the operation/development
to proceed and that there are 'no satisfactory alternatives'.
"Furthermore, the applicant must also meet the test that the
'favourable conservation status' of the species will not be
prejudiced. This is the test that leads to expense being incurred
by the developer/operator. In many cases it means that the animals
need to be moved from their preferred location to newly created
habitats, at the developer/operator's expense."
Secondly, guidance by Natural England in relation to planning
permission issues effectively means that a developer cannot get on
and prepare a site for development by moving protected species away
from it under licence until all the details of the planning have
been completed and signed off.
Ms Histead cautioned: "This is, in our view, an overly
prescriptive and narrow approach which is not justified by the law
and which is open to challenge.
"A further development is the form which now has to be filled
out by the licence applicant which contains an enormous amount of
detail as to the background and need for the project.
"Our advice is to seek legal support."